Technique chat: Shingling
You may have seen my last post, making a fluffy llama. At the end of the last post I still needed to finish his eyes and add eyelashes. Today we were going to consider shingling; adding layers of small amounts of combed fibre or fibre locks in a pattern that mimics the coat on a creature, like that llama I was working on. The fur mimicked by shingling is usually on the longer side, but it can be used for shorter fur too.
When I first started to needle felt, there had been only one option suggested for making a long-ish coat: shingling, with the use of combed top. I now know a number of variations on this technique and a few other options besides it. But let’s look at where I started and a couple of the variations.
As with all the projects I leap into, after the idea, it starts with a bit of fun research to find out what type of fur you want to mimic. Remember to check if there is a summer or winter coat, or if there are regional variations to your animal. It will not look right if you mix the coat of a red wolf with a timber wolf, or have a winter coat on the shoulders and summer coat on the back and legs! Google image search will help, but you have to be careful; sometimes the image descriptions for photos on the internet are labelled wrong. Look for sites that are researching the animal, breed associations, or even hunting groups can have some helpful photos (although not the hunting or cooking parts). It is also helpful to try to get shots from various angles. (I was extremely pleased when I found a picture of the underside of a polar bear foot!)
5.0) chart of coats of animals examples and techniques
For those needle felters who don’t mind getting wet, Sara (of Sarafina fiberarts on YouTube) had been experimenting with making “Pelts”, which are wet felted skin pieces she adds over her shaped felt under structure. Her results have been effective and interesting but do involve getting wet (so I have stayed with the dry techniques for now. I promise I will get brave eventually!)
There are a few things to consider beyond just getting the colour you want and deciding on a working direction to add your shingles (bottom to top or top to bottom; I have seen other felters who work in both directions successfully). Let’s look at some of my variables; you may have more considerations to add to this list.
Variables in shingling you may want to consider:
- Which fibre will best suit your project (there is more than just colour to think about when picking fiber)
- Fibre Staple Length
- Blending your fibres and colours (Blended colour will look more natural than flat colours)
- What scale to work in/ how big or small is your creature?
- Working with locks
- Amount of fibres used in each shingle
- Stacking your shingles
Let’s expand each consideration.
Which fibre will best suit your project: (there is more than just colour to think about when picking fibre)
- Stiff or softer fibre will give a different drape (use photo reference to decide which you need).
- How likely is this fibre to felt to itself from handling or rubbing?
- This is more important if the creature is repositioned regularly (handled).
- Silk, viscose, alpaca, and llama don’t have scales as most wool does, so are less inclined to felt to itself. Wool that has less crimp and outer guard hairs like kemp and tog is also less inclined to cling to itself (felt easily) when handled.
5.1) samples in viscose
- Trim or not to trim (embroidery curved blade, dog grooming scissors/ thinning sheers are options)
- Trimming can occur to shorten the fibre length you are applying, or you can trim the fibres after you have applied the shingles.
- A stiffer fibre vs a softer fibre will also react differently when trimmed by scissors. Stiff fibres can give a more bristle-like appearance when trimmed short.
- Silk, Viscose and similar smooth fibres can be difficult to attach securely to the felted under structure:
- Adding a bit of carded wool or soft spun wool yarn to the area you are securing will help adhere the slippery fibre, like a staple or glue. (You may not need to add assistance to adhere if you are finding it is embedding deeply and securely. Working the fibre in a bit deeper and varying the angle of needle insertion will help it stay without adding extra fibre as glue. If you can’t work a bit deeper, then try adding the staple or glue-like bit of fibre. Remember the extra embedding to secure the fibre will shorten the staple length showing as fur.
5.2 – fibre divided 50/50 felting across to create the shingle
5.3) Add a bit of carded wool or loose spun yarn to attach as glue or a staple to hold the shingle
5.4)Alpaca fibre; folded, tacking folded fibre, and using extra fibre to help hold slippery fibre (staple or glue using loose spun wool yarn or carded fibre)
5.5) sample using Viscose
Using a bit of carded wool as a stable, to help embed the viscose fibre. While a bit of the staple or glue fibre is visible in the sample, using a similar colour as the shingle will make the assisting fibre or yarn invisible. The next layer of shingle will also obscure the previous attachment site.
5.6) For slippery fiber you can also create a wider attachment area
Fibre Staple Length
- If folded, what percentage of the fibre is used.
- Folded in half (50/50 split) was what was first suggested to me. This can create a lot of loft or thickness in the shingle. If folded so cut end is under tips, it will lift the tips and give a thick dense coat.
- Folded (25/75) folded tips on top of longer cut end, gives tips dispersed amongst longer cut end.
- Folded (75/25) folded longer tips on top of cut end, gives lift from the cut end with longer draping tips.
- * You can also use almost all your fibre as coat, and only secure one end (90/10). This is not exactly a folded shingle, but in some cases it’s the proportions that work. You still position it overlapping, as you would in any of the other shingles.
6.1) alpaca samples
- Single needle line of attachment or wider area of needle attachment (for slippery fibre, the wider attachment site can again help the fibre stay attached to your creature)
- Using scissors to shorten the fibre length if needed (we are felters and like scissors!). If you are using combed top, it is easier if you pull off staple lengths then trim, rather than cutting the combed top itself, which will give mixed lengths to deal with (harder to blend and attach)
Pros:
- Twice as fast (except for (90/10))
- Under layer can lift the top layer and make a fluffy-looking coat
- Works well for large colour gradations
Cons:
- Can become heavy-looking depending on the scale of the sculpture
- Can create small colour changes but can be a bit tricky to get exact location
- Fluffy look can be out of scale to smaller figures.
Blending your fibres and colours (Blended colour will look more natural than flat colours)
- Using the same fibre length will blend easily and produce a uniform length of coat.
- Nature is not flat colour. It helps to mix shades and tints of colour to make your creature look more realistic. (Dyeing over a natural grey fibre will also give more depth and subtle variations within the colour)
- Matching colours can be easier if you use a “window”. Cut out a small square in a piece of white or black card stock, leaving at least a 2-inch border to separate the window from the rest of the picture. This lets your eye and brain separate the isolated colour from the background, which makes it easier to colour match.
- Areas with spots of colour change can be easier if switching to smaller amounts of fibre in your shingles (many little shingles). Your other option is to carefully blend the colour changes within the larger staples. The difference is more about the amount of control, suggesting a colour change or spots vs trying to mimic a specific animal’s colour patterns.
- For stripes, you could try to lay in following the colour pattern. I have seen a felter who drew the pattern on her animal then just filled in each adjacent colour section, slowly working up the side of the animal.
7.0) muskox layers of alpaca to make the muskox coat
What scale to work in/ how big or small is your creature?
- Smaller will have less detail but will need to suggest more with what you have. You will also have to use shorter fibers or trim to get the fur in proportion to the size of your creature.
- Larger can have more detail but will require more work and attention to photo reference. Enjoy the process of needle felting and don’t rush.
- As an example of scale, my fox picture has a problem with the whiskers. They are the wrong scale to the image. I used horsetail fibre for the whiskers, and the size is too light in visual weight. I need to find something a bit visually heavier ether a coarser horse tail or possibly the outer coat of a musk ox. I have heard of felters using the bristles from paint brushes (the house painting kind) as whiskers too. (The awl and glue method was used with the paint brush bristles. I used a large eye sewing needle to secure the horse hair.)
7.1) the visual weight of the whiskers is too light for the scale of the image
Working with locks
- Which part(s) of the fibre are you using, Tips only, tips and tails?
8.11-8.12-8.13) Samples with locks
- Locks with crimp are easier to attach than locks with less crimp, like the hair I used on my Mer-people. It’s not a huge difference, but remember to check the fibre is adhering securely and will suit the purpose you intend to use it for. If your creature’s purpose is to sit in one pose on a shelf, you will not need the same security of attachment that a creature that is regularly reposed would require.
- Crimpy curly little locks make fabulous outer coats for little sheep figures and pins. If you find little short locks with lots of crimp, put them aside for a later project if you don’t need them now.
Amount of fibres used in each shingle
- Are you making a puff ball or something sleek? Sample thin layers of shingles vs fewer thicker layers. You may also find the thin layers helpful if you are working with stripes or subtle colour changes.
9.1) ”Crevis” is a soap on a rope hedgehog. I used stiffer fibre and packed it quite tightly to give good scrub-ability. I had fun mixing light colours around the face. I wanted more of an emotional expression of hedgehog rather than an anatomical Hedgehog, since his soapy centre is rectangular and rather flat.
Stacking your shingles (patterns)
- You also can change either the spacing of the shingles or the way the shingles are staggered; (stacked / offset(running bond) / 1/3 offset/shingle pattern / random placement). Looking at the way tile is laid out can give a good reference for shingling patterns. Again, a bit of quick sampling will suggest your best option.
10.1) Wooden shingles, layers offset each row, not necessarily the same size adjacent shingle.
10.2) patterns of subway tile to consider for felting layouts (Straight stack, offset or running bond, 1/3 offset)
10.3) alpaca shingle samples spacing
10.4) Alpaca shingle sample of spacing- side view
- Direction of work: Start from lowest furred area, working to highest, or the other way around. Both work; I just found the former easier than the latter, which requires you to lift the shingles above to position the next below. An example of starting at the lowest point and working up and forward would be my partly 3-D Muskox picture. I also check and see if there is a direction of hair growth and hair fall. This could indicate the direction to lay in the fur.
- How much fibre will you use in each shingle section? If you have areas that have denser fur and areas that are sparser, you may be altering how much you use in different areas and /or the shingle pattern you chose to follow. An example of variations of fur on a single creature would be a Bison or Buffalo. You may also want to use different fibres to mimic the different sections (longer, softer and shorter, stiffer fibre). As long as the colours for the different fibres work cohesively together, your creature will look realistic.
There is also a way to add locks without shingling to create the illusion of fur. I used it to create part of the sheep pins, and Ann uses it on her little sheep figures. Those tiny crimpy curly locks are layered over the surface of the creature in swirls, then tacked down, catching bits of the crimp locks.
10.5) Ann’s Sheep using tight crimpy locks to create the fur/fleece.
Let’s take a quick look at some of the tools I have collected that can be helpful when adding a needle felted fur to a creature.
Tools that may be helpful: (new toys you might like to try)
- Sharp embroidery scissors: straight and curved bladed
- Excellent for careful trimming and getting into difficult spots. The curvature can mimic the curve of your creature. There are various amounts of curvature and length of blade available, so it’s nice to have a couple choices.
11.1) There are a few brands of curved embroidery scissors, as well as fine sewing scissors and curved blade pet trimming scissors
- Pet trimming scissors for thinning coats/salon version for people (look like they have notches along one blade). They are used to thin bulk along the side of hair or at the ends, also for blend transitions, or give movement to hair. They are used teeth side on top and usually at an angle to the hair (perpendicular can give harsher lines if over trimmed).
11.2)Thinning scissors have different teeth spacing that removes different amounts of hair.
If you are really curious, this is a quick video on using them. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lEqi7qfZyOY
- Eyebrow brush and comb (weird original idea, but great for felting). This tiny brush and comb allows you to do small adjustments to your creature’s coat. I saw a tiny mettle comb version, but haven’t seen it again now that I have a use for it.
11.3) Eyebrow tools
- Eyebrow trimmer – strange razor trimmer (again, why is this a thing? Ok I admit my eyebrows never fully arrived so why trim them? What if trimming scares them away and I wind up with none?!) Again, an option for doing fine trimming and adjusting.
- The puffer for blowing lint off your camera lenses; it can help to fluff up a coat or blow out trimmed hairs after using the scissors. It comes in a number of variations, including an electric version that may blow away your creature!
11.4) air blower, originally for cleaning camera equipment
- You could even consider Hair spray or styling gel, but sample first; you don’t want fibre to yellow over time!! (I was a cheap art student (many years ago) and some of the very cheap hair spray we used as fixative did yellow the pastel paper.)
I hope this has sparked a few ideas to consider when adding fur on your creatures. I am sure I had more to add, but the AC seems to be struggling; ok, it’s give up, since it is almost 30C in the house. You may have more options or tools to share; please add your suggestions too.
I hope you have found a cool, possibly air-conditioned spot to felt. Ottawa has been hot with repeated waves of aggressive thunderstorms and flooding (the street west of us had flooded basements; Glenn said ours is still dry, but we did lose the cover to our side door). If you are South of us celebrating your 250th birthday, have fun on the 4th, and hopefully you will get to enjoy your fireworks. Canada Day had spectacular thunderstorms, but fireworks would have been more fun. Have fun, stay cool and keep felting.
6 thoughts on “Technique chat: Shingling”
Fabulous post Jan! We appreciate how much work was involved in writing it and the information you gave will be so useful to needle felters – new and experienced alike.
Doesn’t matter how many times you show your fox, we’ll never get tired of looking at him – he is beautiful and his eye is amazing – it draws you right in.
Was Crevis ever used as a soap? If he was it would have been a shame – he’s too cute!
Unfortunately it’s predicted that we are all going to suffer some high heat days this summer. During the last peak here the coolest room indoors was 32C and made sleeping difficult. Domestic AC here not common 🙁
Thank you both! (your opinions means a lot to me!) i hope the info will spark an AH! moment or send someone down another opion to investigate. Felting is fabulous partly becouse you have so many options to chose from, and you get to stab things legaly!!!
i realy have to get Fox finished its jsut the whiskers than framing!
Crevis was used and looks a bit bedraggled but he has scrubbed with all his might. (i think glenn was cleaner afterwords)
i had herd parts of Urope were very hot and I have been worrying about my internatinal frends. i hope all of them have access to AC at there public library or spend a lot of time in the frozen food section of the grocery store. “do i want this bag of frozen peas or that bag of identical frozen peas?” we just got a new up rite fan from costco, it was still hot for sleeping but with the air moving it was easy to breath. (air moveing is not as good for needle felting or even laying out fiber for wet felting!!!) i hope the weather gives us a brake soon, althouh this i not a request for the snow to return! take care and try to stay cool, it may be time to buy a kiddy wadding pool to sprall in as long as its in the shade!
Jan, your post is great! I, as a needle felter, was thinking how I appreciate the information and how much work you put into it.
It is hot here in New Mexico as well and wish you could send us some of that moisture!! Believe it or not, I was thinking of you yesterday as I was moving my shearing bench and tubs (a double utility sink) I put on it for cleaning my fleece around to the back garden. I got a new drainage hose and will give it a try. I still remember that post you made about draining into the garden and tell all my fleece prepping friends about it!
That’s a very useful post Jan, thanks. Another chapter for your book?
Whiskers – don’t forget that people without opposable thumbs have whiskers which they shed from time to time. I collect any that I find lying around and in cat beds etc. That’s what I used for my hare’s whiskers. They needed shortening, but I just pushed them right through his muzzle, leaving the right amount on the right side and trimming away what stuck out on the wrong side. Because they went so far in, I didn’t need to use glue. Also, you can paint them if your cat doesn’t shed ones the right colour.
I love your description of a bison’s coat – it made me cackle 😄!
Ann
Wonderful post Jan, so much information. I think the idea of wet felted pelts is interesting, I look forward to seeing how that works out for you (once you decide to get wet) 😜
Ruth
What a super-informative post! I don’t think of myself as a needle-felter but this post has my fingers twitching to make something fluffy!
I can see this being one of timeless posts that people will refer back to for years to come, thank you so much for the time and thought you clearly dedicated to writing it.