Buying boxes? Nossir! (or maybe I should have..): how to salvage a misshapen project.

Buying boxes? Nossir! (or maybe I should have..): how to salvage a misshapen project.

Hello, my creative friends.

Here we are at the start of a new and exciting adventure: making a felt box out of, yes, wool!

You think that I am stating the obvious, felt is oftentimes made of wool and of course you can make felt boxes: just look at the internet and you will see tons of them for sale (mostly made with industrial felt)! But you would not believe how many times I have had to explain those two bits of information to people during the time that I was making my box: yes, I am felting it. Yes, it is made of wool. No, I am not going to sew it (if I possibly can), I am felting it. Yes, I make it by felting wool. W-O-O-L. How, you ask? You can make all sorts of shapes by felting with the right resist..no, I am not going to sew it, I assure you it will come out with the box shape. Well, hopefully.

To be sure, a box is just another type of wet felt vessel made with a resist, and yes, of course you can make it by sewing the single felted flat sides and a flat bottom together, but…sewing, where is the fun in that? (total respect to people who like sewing, eh, it is just not me)

Long story medium-short, we decided that we needed to organise our living room in a better way, changing bits of furniture and generally trying to sort out the chaos, also because we are in the process of adopting guinea pigs (oh, my! let’s see) and we need the space for an indoor cage. So, we are plus bookshelves and minus an office desk with drawers, and we need some kind of storage box that fits the shelves and, crucial, does not seem something that you find in your shed. Unfortunately, the size of our shelves is not standard, and a standard storage box will not fit, either because too small or too big. So I thought, let’s have a box that is good to look at and the maximum size that will fit in there, let’s make it ourselves!

(well, I would not want you to think that I normally talk to myself with that royal We. It is clear to any who know me that all that was just me and me thinking “What, 30 pounds for that soulless box that does not even fit properly? no way, I can make one better than that and spend less!” or something of the sort)

A white sheet of paper with measurements for two boxes, a bigger one and a smaller one.
The size of the bookshelves that we have comes in two flavours, big and small, both somewhat non standard, so I originally thought about making a smaller box as well, and took measurements for both. All measurements are in centimeters.
Calculations for a 40 per cent increase on a piece of paper.
I arbitrarily added a 40 % increase on all sides, and did the same also for the height of the lid (all other measurements being the same for lid and box, of course)

To start, I prepared my resist for the bottom of the box: this involved a bit of sewing, namely attaching together the various bits of bubble wrap in the shape of a very floppy box without a top, as I will make a lid to fit it (some time in the far future). It does not show well in photo, but here it is:

A bubble wrap resist is on a floor
Here is the resist seen with the bottom part prominent (naughty).
A resist made of bubble wrap is on a brownish floor with a rug.
And here is the resist bottom down: very floppy, you can not really tell that this is a box shape.

I hate hand sewing on bubble wrap, the plastic just clings firmly to your needle and it is worse than sewing sewing, in my opinion, so let’s not dwell on it.

I did not have as much wool as I needed, so I ordered some from World of Wool. I wanted to try out something different from my usual Merino, as I needed something coarser that could be hard wearing and stand a bit stiffer, because the box is not small and will be full of quite a few things that are on the heavier side, such as tape and packing tape, some cables, and so on. Unfortunately, I am not used to coarser wool, the room was in a chaos and I did not have time for much research on our brilliant Blog or Forum (yes, it is lame. Let’s say, it is not the best excuse for not doing my homework that I have ever found, I’ll admit, but if you give me a bit more time I can say that the guinea pigs have eaten my research), anyway, ahem, later on our wise felt experts from the FFS Forum have determined that apparently I picked the wrong wool.

Well, you know, it can happen to anyone if they skip research and sampling. Well, yes, I also skipped making samples, because, let me think, the guinea pigs ate my sample? OK, maybe not. I’ll get better, pinky promise.

Anyway, I got my generic “English wool” from World of Wool, and yes, it was a bit coarser than Merino but still quite soft..in hindsight I may have been suspicious when it felt so soft, I do not know. Actually, that is a mix of different breeds’ wool, some that may actually be quite good for stiffer felt and some that are not, although they are coarser than Merino. Perfectly fine felting with it for all sorts of uses, but , a word to the wise, do not use it to make big boxes, eh.

A label reading: White 56's English Top, Size 100g, Quantity 6, Total 600g.
Here it is, the challenging wool.

So, I got on my white horse and started felting on my resist straight away with a lot of good will. I assumed that the coarser wool would need less layers to obtain the same felt (do not ask, pre-christmas chaos guinea pigs mind fugue hobblegobble chicachicacha) and I decided on 4 good layers.

Here are a few photos of my felting the first box:

A rectangle of laid out white wool just sprinkled with water, on a bubble wrap.
Starting from the bottom, that was the biggest area.
A work in progress of wet felt in white wool is on a table covered in a white towel and bubble wrap. There is a smaller rectangle covered in a small layer of wool resting over a bigger rectangle covered in white plastic sheets.
First layer on a short side. I took care to cover each already worked on part with a layer of plastic (I used plastic bin bags) as I learned from Lena Archibold’s advice on how to work with a book resist.
Folds wrapped in bubble wrap open over a rectangular shape wrapped in white plastic sheets.
Figuring out how to fold the different sides to get an even result was a bit puzzling at first, I spent some time opening and closing folds, it must have looked weird from outside!
A rectangle of wool pre felt has a layer of Merino wool on top. The Merino wool is half rectangle in orchid color, and bright yellow and teal on the other half rectangle, overlapping a bit the orchid color.
Yes, we are at the fun part of the 5th layer, when I could use dyed Merino wool for the wow effect!
Another rectangular side of the box. There is a rectangle of laid out Merino wool, half the rectangle is teal and half is orchid color, and the two colors overlap a bit.
Here is another side. I actually decorated both four sides, but forgot to take photos of the two smaller. Anyway, it is the same colours for all the sides, only different layout.
A smaller rectangle of wet and soaped Merino wool, with the upper part in teal, a small central line in yellow and a bigger area in orchid color, all slightly overlapping each other.
This is one of the small sides, all wet and soaped, being worked on.
A roll of pre felt is on a wooden table, covered with a white towel and a plastic bubble wrap.
And here we are at the rolling stage. I also used throwing and variously manipulating the shape.

Wait, let’s see if you were attentive: have you noticed that I said “first box”?

Exactly: here is how it stood after drying, that is to say not at all:

A felted object in orchid, teal, yellow and white wool is on a wooden table. The object seems to hold no particular shape.
No words, really.

It took more or less a day to felt, and a few days to dry. I liked the colours (a last layer of Merino wool, the 5th, to do that), and the shape ended up exactly the right size, but it would not stand, and I thought that it was because the layers were just not enough. I had enough wool to start a new one doubling the layers, so I went back to it using the same resist and the same type of wool (not my cleverest day, fine).

A big bag of white wool is being weighted on a scale on a wooden table.
I weighted the remaining wool and I found out that I only had used about 150 grams of it, so I had still about 450 grams to try again.

The steps were the same, only more layers, so I will not show more pics of it, only the final result when the box had dried:

A felted box with the sides slightly collapsing is on a grey sofa.
One side..
A felted box with a side in yellow and teal is on a grey sofa. The sides of the box are collapsing in.
..the other side. I did not decorate the small sides this time, but left them natural white, as they are not going to be seen when the box is in the bookshelf.

It was better, but still the sides were not holding up.

At that point, it was definitely time for my felting fairy godmothers to intervene: I asked the classic “Help, what did I do wrong?” on the Felting and Fiber Studio Forum and, thank goodness, got kind replies that explained the generic English wool issue as probable cause (so, no, adding more layers was likely not going to cure that, in case I still had not clicked on to that) and gave me very good advice on what I could try next to avoid throwing the 2 boxes into the scrap pile and to salvage them.

The suggestions were:

– to try and stiffen the sides or corners with machine or hand stitching

– to try and put a wire armature inside the felt or stitch it on the inside of the box

– to use PVA glue to stiffen the felt

– to stitch the two boxes together one inside the other, and maybe also

– to add some stiff padding, sandwiching it in between the two boxes.

Or possibly to try a combination of the above suggestions until the aim was reached. Which is exactly what I did, apart from the PVA glue and the stitching, both left as last resort, the glue because I was not fancying working with glue with such a big object, and the stitching because I do not have a sewing machine and it takes ages to stitch by hand.

What worked? well, clearly not one thing only, I had to go on trying to the last, but in the end I have a workable box and we are already using it, even though there is no lid yet.

First, I added thick wire to the inside of the box corners, with a few stitches. The felt was not thick enough to insert the wire into it, that would have been better. Sadly, it did not solve the issue totally.

Then, I stitched in place the first box (the thinner one) into the second box, leaving the upper edges open for putting in some padding if required. It was better still, but not there yet.

Lastly, I started looking for padding. Floor underlayer was suggested as good for that job, but when I went to look at my local DIY builders warehouse I did not find the exact type and thickness that I needed, and I came home empty handed. The same research online left me with too many choices, some of them a bit on the expensive side because with a required minimum purchase limit that was also way too high for my storage capability (What, 20 meters rolls minimum?? I do not live in Versailles palace!)

Luckily, as I told you, we were changing some pieces of furniture and it so happens that some had polystyrene sheets in their packaging: initially, I did not want to use that for a few reasons (it breaks easily, it is not going to be washable, it can disperse plastic bits in the environment in time..), but in the end it was there and I could use it instead of chucking it in the garbage bin, so it is kept out of the dump for a little while more. And it was free for me, and readily available.

So, I cut it to size with a knife (bits of polystyrene everywhere, not my idea of fun but the kids where jumping up and down like it was going to be disco party in a minute) and inserted it in the pockets in between the two boxes, and then a quick blanket stitching all around the upper edges did the job. In time I may unstitch it and change the padding, if I will feel so inclined and will have the time.

And here it is, my box done!

(the bottom part, at least)

A felt basket or box without lid, full of miscellaneous objects, on a grey sofa.
That is one side..
A felted basket or box without lid, and full of objects, on a grey sofa.
..and that is the other. Already full of stuff.

Now, for the lid, we will see. Who knows, it might be ready in time for my next blog post..only, don’t hold your breath for it, guinea pigs may be coming and all of that (how did I manage with my lazy excuses before them is a wonder, my friends!)

I hope that you liked my adventures, feel free to leave me a comment, as long as you do not ask me about hand stitching the whole box or preparing resists by hand stitching bubble wrap together, any other thing is totally fine.

Best wishes!

Kiki

@kiki.textile.art

http://www.kikistextileart.com

25 thoughts on “Buying boxes? Nossir! (or maybe I should have..): how to salvage a misshapen project.”

  1. Love the colours in the final layer!
    Quite an adventure and what a good result. Well done for persevering. Experimenting to find what works just makes you a better felter and makes the whole process of feltmaking so enjoyable.
    Thank you for sharing this box-making journey with us – it’s a lovely read and lesson to us all.

    1. Thank you, Lyn. It is surely a journey, and I liked the challenge, to be honest.

  2. I could have sworn I’d posted a comment here, oh well, try again – just like you did Caterina. Well done for persevering and finally fixing the problems. I didn’t realise, when you asked for help on the Forum, just how big the box was you were trying to make – it looks great, most definitely better than a wooden one, even without a lid.
    Ann

    1. Thank you for your comment, Ann!
      😅 yes, the box is big, no sense in starting a rushed project headlong without samples and research if it is going to be a tiny bitty thing, don’t you agree? This way, I really had to make it work one way or the other, so I had not wasted wool and time and effort for nothing!😅
      I am glad that you like the result, I bet no wooden box is so colourful, and it fits our shelf perfectly!

    1. Thank you! Yes, making things with your hands can be very rewarding, but one needs to keep trying!

  3. Wow! You do like a challenge. It now looks perfect for your perseverance and didn’t get tossed in the incomplete bin like I would do. Thanks for the fun read!

    1. Thank you, Donna.
      I am not usually that patient, but we needed the box 😅

  4. That was a rollercoaster of emotions! I’m loving your perseverance, I’d have thrown my resolve out the window and just sewn the parts together! Very cute box, you should be proud 🙂

    Now, may I borrow your piggies for when I need an excuse to not get work done?… I’d like to start blaming other animals besides my poor cats.

    1. Thank, you, Leonor.
      Sure, go ahead, be my guest, use my future piggies whenever you feel like, they are bound to be more messy than a flock of seagulls in rampage from now on in all of our posts!

  5. I like your box too; wonderful solution to the problem! I have had a similar problem at one time, and managed to find some double walled cardboard, and my problem was solved.
    I love the colour and size of the box, and the triumphant result.

    1. Thank you, Marie. Properly thick cardboard would have been perfect as well, I agree, and even better than brittle polystyrene. I may swap the polystyrene for something else in time.

  6. You have certainly carried us with you on your experimental and challenging journey. Kudos for your perseverance.

    The result is one to be justly proud of.

    1. Thank you, Antje! Very kind. Experimental and challenging are great words to describe it 😅 instead of rushed and other less flattering words, say. 🤣 I am lucky that the FFS Forum is there, I always learn so much from you all.

  7. Well done on keeping on even though those troublesome piggies kept getting in the way. I would like to see photos of those culprits when possible. The box looks great and you learned a lot so that’s the point in my opinion.

    1. Thank you, Ruth.
      Yes, and I would like to point out that I not only have a box for my shelves now, I also have a blog post done out of it all, that is a very good outcome quite apart from all the learning 😅. I have also lost my fear of coarser wool, I guess, and I have used that English 56’s with Merino, and it felted beautifully, so I can use the remaining for all sorts of other projects.
      All that, and the piggies are not here yet: what might I do after they arrive, I wonder!
      We are meeting some prospective piggies at the rescue on Saturday, fingers crossed.

  8. Well you really got your brain and body work out. It ended up great and the box is colourful inside and out. I wouldn’t have thought to make the resist like that. I am always thinking of what it would look like if I flattened it. I had been thinking about making a box so maybe I will have to try. Next is a couple of classes so next blog topic is set.

    1. Thank you, Ann.
      I am so glad that you mentioned a different way to make the resist: I am all for thinking about resist shapes. Which shape would work well for a box, do you think? I just did not have other ideas, but surely there are other resist shapes to try!

    2. I made one using a book resist, though it was a square box (cube). I’m not sure what shape book resist would make a rectangle though. Perhaps Ann can tell us?
      Ann

  9. That was one very creative adventure you undertook Caterina. What a lovely colourful result. I would never have thought of your resist shape, ingenious. Your box holds lots and will look great on your new shelves.

    Best of luck with the new additions to the family. I bet the children are very excited. Lots of promises about all the chores they will take on when the pair arrive!
    Helene x

    1. Thank you, Hélène.
      What kind of shape would you have gone for to make a box? I feel that it is super interesting to talk about resist shapes, as there is a lot of creativity involved!

      The piggies are not here yet, so the promises are pouring in: let’s see if we will see a drought of actions as soon as the actual creatures are inside the house. I hope not, but I am not betting on this. 🙂
      Xx

    2. The boxes I have made have been cubes Caterina. I have one out in my garden at present – a rather angular bird house – we are talking Brutalism here.
      The book resist looked like a square with a triangle top and bottom (4 pages).
      I imagine that if one was to elongate the square into a rectangle and keep the dimensions of the triangles it would become a felted rectangle. Then one of the rectangular sides would be cut into at prefelt stage – this would help reinforce the sides of the rectangle. All off the top of my head Caterina, I haven’t done the maths lol
      Helene x

We would love to hear your thoughts!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.